“I got grabbed and detained by cops this morning, but then released (thanks to Samuel and Brenda for being there to de-escalate the cops and for sticking around) for apparently inciting a vehemently anti-refugee crowd.
I was on my way to work and saw tons of banners claiming Trudeau is responsible for the murder of Marissa Shen. For those who don’t know, Marissa Shen was a 13-year old girl who was murdered in Burnaby in 2017. Her murder was devastating, and particularly so in Burnaby (close to my extended family’s place) as it was in Central Park where so many families, especially immigrant families, congregate. A few months ago Ibrahim Ali was charged, and the media has been hyper-focused on the fact that he arrived to Canada as a church-sponsored refugee from Syria.
This has had huge ripple effects. Faith Goldy has been picking up on this. Laura Thompson, who is running to be school trustee as a white supremacist anti-SOGI candidate, was a previous similar rally. I am obviously not a fan of Trudeau, but he’s become the target for letting in ‘too many refugees’ by the fascist white supremacist right by people like Goldy and Thompson and Ibrahim’s migration background – which should not be relevant- is now part of their arsenal. This is part of a frightening global trend with escalating white supremacist rhetoric and policies against refugees esp Muslim refugees in Europe.
I walked by the rally and started talking to a group of people about why they were focused on the refugee process, and explaining how the refugee process is already too stringent, expressing my concern that this fixation on his refugee background has contributed to a strong overall anti-refugee climate (and i know this concretely because i have been talking to progressive churches about sanctuary for a family who are facing deportation and the churches are worried about the hostility and can’t take on sanctuary at this moment), and why weren’t we talking about violence against women and girls and vulnerability to violence as a priority instead.
The conversation is heated and I keep getting baited about ‘supporting murderers’ and my own personal background (am i a mom, a canadian, my ethnicity and religious background)
As soon as media cameras noticed the conversation, the whole rally surrounds me, I can’t physically leave, and they start yelling and baiting me with: (I probably dont have the order of everything right coz it was intense and all in all was around 20 mins or so)
“no bail for murderers’ ’ you support murderers’.”
I respond that I work and am connected to a community reeling from the grief of serial murderers.
“how do you know the pain of a mother, you probably aren’t a mother.”
Yes I am
“Are you a Muslim”
No I am Sikh, but so what if I was.
“Sikhs have created so many religious problems too”
Wow. That’s a fcked up thing to say.
I start to respond more fully to that one, but then loud chanting begins:
“We don’t want a refugee flood.” “More screening for refugees”
There isn’t a flood, Canada accepts less than 0.01 percent of the worlds’ refugees. And aren’t you here for some reason of your own? (the crowd is entirely Chinese folks).
“Are you a refugee? We are hard working Canadian citizens”
A guys spits on me and at me, so I can’t even respond to that one. I move back, the cops move in. Cops tell me I am obstructing, I start to debate with the cops about how that is even possible given that i am surrounded and its public space, then they tell me I am inciting a crowd – a crowd that is literally surrounding me and chanting over me about ‘Don’t support murderers. No bail. Screen refugees’.
More happened in between and the cops grab me, but I was tearing and close to crying at the end. Not from debate or confrontation – that is familiar though never comfortable – but because this is the brutal fucking reality of some immigrants with deeply conservative values that align with capitalism and white supremacy, of working with and supporting women dealing with daily endemic violence and to have a horrific murder of a young girl suddenly become about everything *except* violence against women and girls, of being forced to defend a government policy that is so abyssal to begin with, of not knowing if this one family – or any other family – will be able to get church sanctuary anytime soon because of this huge chill effect, of being overwhelmed by the number of people i know who are in detention right now facing deportation who have a right to be free.
At the end, one woman comes over to talk for bit, we have a decent conversation about the problematic anti-refugee rhetoric and how suddenly the conversation has pivoted to refugees when before he was charged there is some discussion about increased safety for women and girls in the area – which was a more relevant and necessary conversation. We hug and she gives me a flower and asks if I will attend her chinese womens book club that has been talking about this. I say yes and she gets my number. Samuel Holmes graciously encourages her to see the big picture too.
But the intensity and immensity has me shook and I feel even more frustrated at how deep multi racial, cross community, racial justice work and relations is sorely lacking in our city.“
–
Submitted by @theslightestwords.