blackreapersreign:

In regards to this happening:

It makes little sense for him to openly accuse his brother like that, in front of everyone, especially when he said that he’d stand firmly against anyone who’d want to hurt him for his lies.

Undertaker comments on bizarre dolls and their ability to lie here.

“Their mouths that cannot clamor noisily or tell lies any longer.” I mean, he could be referring to bizarre dolls not being able to speak anymore, but that… I don’t think that’s the case. He didn’t intend to have his bizarre dolls never speaking again, did he?

Apparently, if you look behind the psychology of lying, you’ll find out that feelings are strongly related to lies. Most people lie because of certain feelings, but, if what real!Ciel lacks is feelings, he might not be able to lie per se. That would be an interesting affair, considering how much of Black butler’s plot is based on lies.

Either way, real!Ciel doesn’t make a big deal of his brother lying. Chapter 140:

So when he’s telling everyone that his brother has been pretending to be him, he’s like, “Oh, he said he was me! Haha! Isn’t he so cute?”

The latest chapter (143) also lowkey hints at this.

But was there any need for him to admit that he was incapacitated? By admitting this, if you also take into account that Lord Sirius needed blood, he almost confessed that he was the one who needed blood – which is weird. He could have made up a lie somehow, but he didn’t. Maybe he couldn’t.

What’s also very interesting about real Ciel is the extreme change between when he was alive and now, when he’s a bizarre doll. Perhaps it’s because he doesn’t feel emotions anymore, so he’s more blunt. Or perhaps he can’t filter his reactions anymore – he can’t lie.

His reaction to Sebastian talking:

roast him boi

It’s so blunt and straight forward.

Anyway, this is just a small theory. Thank you for reading, if you actually took the time to do it. Any thoughts on it?